Fed Officials Differ On Rate Path, But Predominant View is To Proceed Gradually

By Steven K. Beckner

(MaceNews) – As the days dwindled until the Federal Reserve’s final monetary policy meeting of the year, Fed officials continued this week to express support for further interest rate hikes, but the predominant view remained that the central bank should stay on a gradual course rather than escalate the pace of rate hikes to battle inflation.

What remains in doubt is the amount and frequency of rate hikes in 2027, as Chairman Kevin Warsh and his colleagues prepare to assess the economic outlook.

The Fed chief had a chance to send a different signal when he spoke Monday morning, but if anything his upbeat comments about the prospects for productivity growth seemed to bespeak optimism about the inflation outlook, at least in the longer run.

Once again, it was left to a key Warsh lieutenant, New York Federal Reserve Bank President John Williams, to deploy the code of incrementalism, declaring Tuesday that the Fed’s policymaking Federal Open Market Committee does not need to resort to “drastic action” when it convenes Dec. 8-9.

Federal Reserve Board Vice Chairman Phillip Jefferson was less explicit Thursday morning, but his very deliberate approach of monitoring risks to both sides of the Fed’s “dual mandate” conveyed much the same message.

Much more hawkish noises came from other quarters.

A prairie storm of hard-hitting monetary policy commentary blew out of Missouri early in the week, as two Federal Reserve Bank presidents from the “Show Me” state – Kansas City’s Jeffrey Schmid and St. Louis’s Alberto Musalem – called for strong action to bring down inflation.

Musalem in particular was unusually blunt Tuesday, not only calling for higher rates “soon,” but declaring that “the economy will likely require several interest rate increases before the spring of 2027 to achieve 2% inflation in a timely manner.”

Cleveland Federal Reserve Bank President Beth Hammack reiterated her preference for gradual, incremental tightening moves Monday, but she suggested that if limited measures fail to gain control of inflation, the Fed might have to take more aggressive steps, particularly if inflation expectations were to become unanchored.

Gov. Christopher Waller reaffirmed his support for a 50 basis point rate hike on Wednesday. At the very least, he said, the FOMC will need to signal additional rate hikes early in the new year if it only moves by 25 basis points on Dec. 9.

Other officials have expressed a range of views, but the common theme was that the FOMC must “deliver price stability,” as Warsh has continually asserted since succeeding Jerome Powell as chairman in May.

Minutes of the contentious Oct. 27-28 FOMC meeting, released Wednesday, provided an unusually detailed description of participants’ policy views. The main thrust was that, although the overwhelming majority was willing to stand pat then, nearly everyone was prepared to resume rate hikes to some degree and possibly shift to more vigorous tightening if the inflation outlook were to darken. But there was no clear consensus on how often and by how much the FOMC will need to raise rates in coming months.

After a nine-month stay at 3.50%-3.75%, which was preceded by 175 basis points of rate cuts, the FOMC unanimously raised the federal funds rate by 25 basis points on Sep[t. 16 to a 3.75-4.0% target range. The Committee then split 10-2 to keep the policy rate unchanged on Oct. 28, with two members (Hammack and Gov. Lisa Cook) wanting the FOMC raise it again.

At the upcoming meeting, FOMC participants, excluding Warsh, will revise their quarterly Summary of Economic Projections, and it seems likely that after fulfilling their September projection of one more 2026 rate hike on Dec. 9, the Fed governors and presidents will project further rate hikes in 2027. Certainly, that is the market expectation.

The median projection in the September SEP was that the funds rate would remain at 4.1% (a range of 4.0% to 4.25%) throughout 2027 following a final 25 basis point rate hike before the end of 2026).

But since then, data have augmented the case for additional tightening. Notably, the October employment report, which showed non-farm payrolls having risen a much stronger than expected 165,000, coupled with sharp upward revisions to prior months, while the unemployment rate dipped to 4.1%. And the October Consumer Price Index rose a greater than expected 0.4% (0.3% for the core CPI).

Those and other data reinforced officials’ concerns about inflation and their confidence that the economy is strong enough to withstand anti-inflationary monetary measures.

But Fed officials have differing perspectives on inflation. While some are alarmed or anxious, others have a greater sense of equanimity, or cautious optimism.

Warsh refrained from making any major policy statements, as he opened the Fed’s Productivity and Jobs Task Force conference at the Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco on Monday. But his tone betrayed a lack of enthusiasm for aggressive tightening in the near-term.

The FOMC has its share — perhaps an increasing share — of anti-inflation zealots. Hawkish sentiment seems to have grown in some quarters.

Before the work week even began, Schmid journeyed to Hawaii to tell the National Credit Union Management Association that the inflation threat has grown since Warsh told the Kansas City Fe’s August Jackson Hole symposium that “the Fed has some work to do on inflation.”

“Unfortunately, our work has only gotten harder since then,” he said. “Inflation has been running too hot.”

Schmid said the Fed’s preferred PCE inflation measure, most recently reading 3.6% annually, is “uncomfortably above the 2% price stability target, and moving in the wrong direction.” He added that the October CPI data showed inflation “far too high.”

Countering arguments that inflation has been temporarily elevated by “unfavorable supply shocks” over which the Fed has “little influence,” he said “this view neglects that inflation is always the result of an imbalance” between supply and demand.

“Demand always plays a role in inflation, and the Fed, through its influence on demand, always has the tools and responsibility to address inflation,” Schmid asserted, adding that it is not true that,“ Inflation is somehow beyond the Fed’s power to control … . The Fed does have the tools to address inflation and has the responsibility to achieve price stability.”

Musalem, speaking in Buenos Aires Tuesday, said, “Inflation is elevated and broad-based, and I perceive meaningful risk that above-target inflation will persist longer than is consistent with price stability.”

A  respected monetary economist in his own right before becoming St. Louis Fed President in April 2024, he said “current policy is not yet restraining inflation.”

“Further removal of monetary policy accommodation will be required soon,” Musalem said. “The economy will likely require several interest rate increases before the spring of 2027 to achieve 2% inflation in a timely manner.  In the likely scenario, I expect the economy will require a real policy rate solidly between 2% and 2.5% before the spring of 2027.”

Waller, who had already come out conditionally in favor of a 50 basis point rate hike last week, strongly reaffirmed that viewpoint Wednesday on CNBC. If the FOMC does not go that big, it should at least signal another 25 basis point rate hike at the Jan. 26-27 meeting, he declared, notwithstanding Warsh’s outspoken opposition to the use of “forward guidance.’

“People have argued, do you do 50 in December, nothing in January, or 25 in December, 25 in January,” Waller told CNBC. “But when you do 25 now and you’re going to do 25 in January, it only affects market pricing if you signal you’re going to do it, and you give the markets a credible signal.”

“If you’re not going to signal this very clearly to markets you’re going in January, my view is then you have to go 50 in December,” he added.

October 28 dissenter Hammack also cemented her hawkish reputation Tuesday on Bloomberg.

Although she said she “likes moving in smaller increments,” she warned, “If we get behind the curve and we ⁠need to put more restriction in, we absolutely can move in those larger increments.”

Not only is inflation too high, but there may be “emerging” signs of labor market tightness, Hammack said.  “It could be that both sides (of the dual mandate) are really pointing to that need for more restriction in the economy, and that could change the ​end destination of where ​we need to get ⁠to.”

More hawkishness came from Chicago Fed President Austan Goolsbee Tuesday. Although he  stopped short of endorsing jumbo rate hikes, the 2027 voter warned of the need for the Fed not to fall behind in the fight against inflation .

“At this moment, we’ve got to be very cognizant that we’re dancing on the edge of something that’s hard and potentially painful to get rid of,” he said, pointing to “negative shocks” that are pushing up prices , as well as “demand overheating,” and warning against a deterioration of inflation expectations.

“If people start taking for granted that inflation is going to be this high next year, the year after, et cetera, then they start factoring it into their decisions,” said Goolsbee.

But “cooler heads” seem likely to prevail on Dec. 9, based on comments from the Fed leadership triumvirate.

Warsh confined himself to musings about “super intelligence” and productivity Monday, when he could have decided to send a more pointed policy message.

Looking at potential scenarios, the Fed chief said, “SI  leads to an increase in productivity and economic gains that are shared broadly across labor and the owners of capital. In that event, real GDP growth rises persistently above its long-run average, and the U.S. stays close to full employment.”

Alternatively, Warsh said “an SI-driven expansion could bring substantial labor market disruption as some jobs are displaced, rather than complemented, by technology. GDP growth would still rise above its long-term average. But widespread automation, combined with labor market frictions, could push the jobless rate above levels consistent with full employment.”

“Or SI could disappoint,” he went on. “After significant capital investment and stock market gains, expected returns could turn down and equity valuations could fall, leading to an economic slowdown and a more notable rise in unemployment. In time, the economy would recover, but without the productivity gains.”

Williams was far less shy about addressing near-term monetary policy issues.

The FOMC Vice Chairman, who is more optimistic about inflation than some of his colleagues, said he sees no need for “dramatic action” at this point.

“I think what we’ve been doing over the last, past few months … is working well,” Williams told an Axios BFD Annual Summit Tuesday.

“We still ‌have our work to do ⁠to make sure that we bring inflation back down to 2% in a timely way and in a sustained manner,” he said, but now is not the time for “dramatic action.”

Jefferson was more subtle, but his balanced approach also suggested there is no need for the FOMC to panic and raise rates more aggressively. “Our task is to remain attentive to our respective mandates and to keep the stance of our policies appropriately calibrated to achieve those stated goals,” he said. “For the U.S. economy, my goal is to restore price stability while maintaining a solid labor market. That outcome will help the economy grow according to its full potential.

Jefferson did lay out circumstances in which the FOMC might need to take stronger measures in the future, but he spoke in a conditional vein.

“An energy price shock can push up inflation while weighing on real incomes and demand,” he said. “The appropriate response depends on the relative costs of missing each objective and the balance of risks.”

Jefferson noted that “when the recent energy price shock occurred, inflation in the U.S. was already above our 2 % target.,”

He said that “if inflation expectations risk becoming unanchored, a stronger reaction to inflation is warranted,” but added, “If price pressures are contained, it may be prudent to prioritize downside risks to employment.”

Jefferson went on to observe that “currently, the AI buildout is exerting upward pressure on demand and inflation.” But he added, “In the future, advancements in productivity could exert downward pressure on inflation while continuing to support growth.”

Among other officials who have spoken in recent days, Gov. Michael Barr said Wednesday that “if the economy evolves ​as I currently forecast, I expect ​it will be appropriate to raise ⁠rates further.”

“Inflation is too high, making it hard for American families to ​make ends meet,” he said, adding “The economy is strong, with low ​unemployment, solid ​consumer spending, ⁠and robust business investment,” Barr said.

Minneapolis Fed President Neel Kashkari, an FOMC voter, seemed to question whether the FOMC has monetary policy set appropriately when he observed that financial markets appear to believe that rates will need to go higher than Fed officials expect.

Minutes of the October meeting show a wide spectrum of policy opinions, and that seems to have continued.

In general, the minutes say FOMC participants  “stressed the importance of restoring inflation to 2% percent on a sustained basis, preventing persistent relative-price shocks from giving rise to broad inflation pressures, and maintaining well-anchored inflation expectations.”

But when it came to how to attack the inflation problem, officials diverged. The minutes say “most participants expressed support for maintaining the target range for the federal funds rate.”

Their reasons differed. “Many of these participants pointed to benefits in accumulating additional information, which would help in determining the policy stance appropriate to ensure a timely return of inflation to the Committee’s 2% goal,” according to the minutes. “These participants cited the need to assess the durability of AI-related investment demand, the evolution of financing conditions, the transmission of the September rate increase to the economy, or geopolitical developments.”

But the minutes add, “a couple of participants noted that, at the current juncture, a gradual approach to policy firming would give businesses and households time to adjust to higher interest rates.”

And “several participants emphasized that monetary policy’s stance and the effects of that stance should be evaluated by considering the overall path of the federal funds rate over time rather than actions taken at individual meetings.”

Further, the minutes disclose that “some participants observed that market-implied expectations of tightening steps in December and next year were broadly consistent with their assessments of the appropriate policy rate path, and several saw this alignment as reducing the risks associated with keeping the target range unchanged at this meeting.”

But “a few participants, while supporting maintaining the current target range for the federal funds rate, indicated that they viewed the decision as a close call.”

And “many participants stressed the importance of clearly relaying the message that the decision to maintain the target range did not reflect a weakening of the Committee’s commitment to returning inflation to 2% in a timely manner.”

The minutes say “some participants favored an increase of 25 basis points in the target range at this meeting, emphasizing that inflation had remained too high and that they saw few signs of it abating. They judged that the current policy stance was not sufficiently restrictive, and a few of them warned that further delay risked allowing high inflation to become entrenched or necessitating a larger and more disruptive tightening later.”

But “a few participants who favored an increase in the target range indicated that they could have supported no change in the federal funds rate provided that it was clearly understood by market participants that further tightening was likely.

Looking ahead, the minutes say “almost all participants judged that, under their baseline outlooks for inflation and the labor market, further action to raise the target range for the federal funds rat — broadly consistent with the September Summary of Economic Projection — would likely be appropriate, in order to ensure a timely return of inflation to the 2% objective.”

The minutes add that “a couple of participants noted that an increase of more than 25 basis points could warrant consideration at the next meeting if incoming inflation data were unfavorable.”

And “a few participants observed that inflation could prove more persistent than anticipated, in which case a shift to a more restrictive policy stance could become necessary.”

Share this post